DVD Breakdown
Full reviews Capsule reviews Features Links About us
An American in Paris (1951)

Vincente Minnelli
Gene Kelly, Leslie Caron, Georges Guétary, Oscar Levant, Nina Foch
Anamorphic widescreen
Dolby Digital 5.1
DTS
Trailer(s)
Featurette(s)
Documentary
Audio commentary
Deleted scenes
Concept art / storyboards
Multi-angle feature
Quote
Jerry Mulligan (Gene Kelly): Back home everyone said I didn't have any talent. They might be saying the same thing over here, but it sounds better in French.

Plot summary
An American painter living in Paris falls in love with a French girl but soon encounters several complications.

Film review
Although it's been overtaken in popularity and acclaim by Kelly's bouncier, more plot-driven and less highbrow Singin' in the Rain, An American in Paris was by far the more celebrated film of its time. Both films have their strengths and weaknesses, but without going into a detailed discussion on which of these musical masterpieces is the better picture, a quick survey of some of their most notable similarities and differences makes for an interesting comparison. Both films feature Gene Kelly as the sympathetic hero with a humorous sidekick, a romantic interest and a second female character whose one-sided romantic interest in Kelly forms the largest hurdle for him to overcome.

Both films also have a tendency towards self-reflexivity, foregrounding the artificiality of film in different ways: Singin' in the Rain features many jokes and double layers because it is set in Hollywood, while An American in Paris calls attention to its own tricks by opening the film with three consecutive bits of voice-over narration that address the viewer and even correct the audience's assumed conclusions. Finally, both films feature an extended ballet sequence that has little to do with the furthering of the film's narrative. For Singin' in the Rain, with its efficient, cleverly constructed plot, the 'Broadway Melody' sequence seems out of place. But the final ballet in An American in Paris, offering a dreamlike recap of parts of the slim plot, is easily the highlight of the film, a gorgeous spectacle of pure cinema that transcends the film's immensely witty but thinly constructed narrative.
Version control
First released on DVD for Region 1 by MGM/UA, with a differently packaged but otherwise identical release following later from Warner, which has since also issued a similar disc for Region 2.

Picture and sound
The fullscreen image is framed at its original aspect ratio of approx. 1.33:1. For this transfer, a source print was used that was in reasonable shape, with good sharpness and generally impressive skintones. But the image does suffer from the many nicks, scratches and intrusive discolorations that tend to hamper aging Technicolor films: green blobs pop up throughout, and the color palette tends to shift noticeably around reel changes and overworn scenes. Overall, it's an acceptable presentation with strong moments, but the print is clearly in need of a full restoration job along the lines of Singin' in the Rain.
The original mono sound mix is presented in Dolby Digital 2.0. Hardly any of the historic recordings for this picture exist in anything but monaural sound, and the entire picture has that thin-sounding, tinny and distorted sound that characterize films of this period.

Added value
The theatrical trailer is - sadly - the only extra found on this release.Simple, rather blandly designed static menu pages offer access to the main feature and limited options.

Dan Hassler-Forest

Reviewed: 2003

Click here for IMDB info on An American in Paris.

Click here to return to the front page.

© 2000-2006. A Remediated publication. All Rights Reserved. Site hosted by True