DVD Breakdown
Full reviews Capsule reviews Features Links About us
Barry Lyndon (1977)

Stanley Kubrick
Ryan O'Neal, Marisa Berenson, Patrick Magee
Anamorphic widescreen
Dolby Digital 5.1
DTS
Trailer(s)
Featurette(s)
Documentary
Audio commentary
Deleted scenes
Concept art / storyboards
Multi-angle feature
Quote
Narrator: Her Ladyship and Barry lived, after a while, pretty separate. She preferred the quiet, or - to say the truth -, he preferred it for her, being a great friend to modest and tranquil behavior in woman.

Plot summary
A penniless Irishman seeks his fortune in eighteenth-century England.

Film review
Best known for its technical achievements in cinematography, Barry Lyndon is without a doubt Stanley Kubrick's most overlooked, undervalued work, deserving of much more praise than most of his more controversial works of his late career. Following the enormous controversy that surrounded A Clockwork Orange, many simply didn't know what to make of this languid, episodic, and meticulously designed three-hour sojourn into the past. Indeed, those who proclaim themselves Kubrick fans for the sake of the kinetic shocks and disturbances of Clockwork, The Shining and Full Metal Jacket may find little to enjoy here, and dismiss it as a 'coffee table book of a movie'.

But Barry Lyndon is much more than the pretty but shallow length of period drama it has been labelled far too often. The constant wit of its screenplay, the breathtaking perfection of staging, framing and lighting, and the wholly convincing recreation of a period brought to life for once without jokey anachronisms or stilted stuffiness, but with a language, a code and a landscape all its own is an accomplishment one can only marvel at. Kubrick was outraged by the fact that he had overestimated both his audience and his critics, all of whom were thrown for a loop by Barry Lyndon. And I'm sure that some of this anger is what fuelled the rage at the core of his next project, The Shining, which he was determined to see a commercial success. It's a pity that many still need convincing in making a case for Barry Lyndon. But looking back over Kubrick's long and diverse career, one could perhaps safely argue that Barry Lyndon was indeed something of a masterpiece, and the last truly great film Kubrick ever made.
Version control
The first DVD release of Barry Lyndon was available separately or as part of the original Region 1 release of the Stanley Kubrick Collection box set, and featured a rather soft transfer drawn from damaged source elements.
A remastered edition was released earlier this year for Region 1, again both separately and as part of the newly remastered Stanely Kubrick Collection box set, and features a cleaned-up transfer.
The Region 2 release of Barry Lyndon features the remastered version of the film, and is available both separately and as part of the newly released Stanley Kubrick Collection box set. The Region 2 release, which is identical to the R1 version, served as basis for this review.

Picture and sound
Unfortunately for all those with widescreen TV sets or projectors, Warner Home Video's policy is to release non-anamorphic transfers of films with a 1.66:1 aspect ratio, and contrary to what the Region 2 packaging would claim, Barry Lyndon is no exception. But although a windowboxed anamorphic transfer would probably have pleased the majority of DVD buyers more, the transfer on this newly restored and remastered presentation is no less than outstanding. The image's general softness is part and parcel of the original look of the film, which is presented here more accurately than ever before on home video. The source elements are free of dirt and scratches, and the often breathtaking tableaux on display throughout the film are presented with marvelous detail and consistent colors.
The new Dolby Digital 5.1 sound mix brings forth a finely judged widening of the front soundstage that breathes new life into the impeccable use of music throughout the film. The dialogues sound clear and warm, without any evident distortion, and very occasional use of the rear channels gives the soundstage just the required bit of depth.

Added value
The theatrical trailer is the only extra on this disc.The static menu screens are presented in anamorphic widescreen and are accompanied by a music cue from the score.

Dan Hassler-Forest

Reviewed: 2001

Click here for IMDB info on Barry Lyndon .

Click here to return to the front page.

© 2000-2006. A Remediated publication. All Rights Reserved. Site hosted by True