DVD Breakdown
Full reviews Capsule reviews Features Links About us
Blue Velvet  (1986)

David Lynch
Kyle McLachlan, Isabella Rosselini, Dennis Hopper, Laura Dern, Dean Stockwell
Anamorphic widescreen
Dolby Digital 5.1
DTS
Trailer(s)
Featurette(s)
Documentary
Audio commentary
Deleted scenes
Concept art / storyboards
Multi-angle feature
Quote
radio announcer: It's a beautiful day, so get those chainsaws out!

Plot summary
A young man visiting his provincial hometown finds a human ear in a field, leading him to strange and dangerous discoveries.

Film review
The surreal, semi-experimental horror comedy Eraserhead may have been David Lynch's cinematic début, but following the mainstream success of The Elephant Man and the disastrous Dune, it was Blue Velvet that succeeded in touching a real nerve amongst audiences and critics, and that ended up defining the director's reputation. Indeed, most of Lynch's most typical characteristics are on display here, albeit in a somewhat raw, undeveloped form. Most prominent in Blue Velvet is the dream logic that defines the narrative from Jeffrey's finding of the ear onward. Every further step into the dark, sinister but inexplicably compelling world that he discovers can be read as being representative of the two exaggerated extremes of his moral compass: 'good', as defined by 1950s Hollywood-inspired smalltown values, and absolute 'evil', as personified by Frank Booth. His dream-exploration of this basic difference between right and wrong yields some unexpected revelations about his identity, including his voyeuristic tendencies and odd sexual tastes.

As in a dream, there is plenty of incident, many of which remains unexplained, continuously thwarting audience expectations, especially because his dream world is constructed from elements that seem familiar from other films. But the diverse narrative and stylistic elements are often at odds with each other: the damsel in distress he sets out to save conflicts with the more traditional romantic interest as personified by Sandy (Laura Dern), while what would at first appear to be the film's main mystery (whose ear did Jeffrey find and why?) is only dealt with fleetingly, its background and development never fully revealed.

These unresolved plot elements give the film its surreal uncomfortable edge that retains its power after fifteen years and repeated viewings. It lacks the focus and refinement Lynch would later display in the Twin Peaks pilot, Lost Highway and especially Mulholland Dr. The great mix between humor and horror that is Lynch's unique talent seems a little off-balance here, with long sections of unmitigated nastiness at times taking on a near-assaultive nature that can be fatiguing. There is however a sense of honesty and unfiltered visions from the subconscious that make this a powerful, raw and visceral experience that may not always be fun but that makes for memorable, groundbreaking cinema.
Version control
First released on various bonestock DVD editions for Region 1 and Region 2, all with unimpressive audio and video, and more recently issued by MGM/UA for both regions as a solid Special Edition with a new, director-supervised transfer and sound mix and several extras on board, including a 70-minute documentary. The recent Special Edition served as a basis for this release.

Picture and sound
The anamorphic widescreen image is framed at an aspect ratio of approx. 2.35:1. This new, director-supervised transfer is about as good as it gets: grain is all but absent, and colors are bright and bold. The many scenes that take place in near-absolute darkness also look terrific, with a good spectrum of deep blacks and greys, and plenty of shadow detail. A slight softness to the image is the only detractor from an otherwise outstanding visual presentation.
The new Dolby Digital 5.1 sound mix is also excellent, with plenty of strong, deep bass and decent fidelity. The sound desing clearly favors the front soundstage, with rear activity mostly limited to support of the orchestral score and ambient sounds. The dialogues have a fairly limited dynamic range, and the sound elements have a slightly fuzzy nature that betrays their age. But considering the limitations of the source material, this is clearly as good as Blue Velvet will ever look or sound on home video.

Added value
The main extra on board this new Special Edition release is the 70-minute documentary, conveniently divided into themed chapters. It includes generous new interview footage with most major participants of cast and crew. Lynch himself proves characteristically elusive, but shows up more often than expected in plenty of archival interview footage. Apparently, the director's refusal to discuss his films is a fairly recent development, as we do end up seeing a much younger Lynch talking about several aspects of the film's production and development in great detail. The other participants all have plenty of interesting observations and amusing anecdotes, and the film does a fine job of presenting what is likely to be the definitive Blue Velvet making-of documentary.

Lynch's first cut of the film ran a reported four hours, and one can't help but wonder what exactly ended up on the cutting room floor. Sadly, this deleted footage appears to be lost forever, but the DVD producers did put together an intriguing montage of dialogue recordings and music cues accompanying still photography in an effort to approximate what some of those scenes might have looked like. The montage presents what may have been ten sequences from an earlier cut, including some fascinating material. Also included is a minute-and-a-half excerpt from the Siskel & Ebert review of the film, in which they debate Rossellini's unsettling nude appearance towards the film's end. They hold conflicting opinions about the film and about this scene (Siskel liked it, Ebert didn't), and their discussion makes for a nice inclusion and telling demonstration of the controversy surrounding the film at the time. There's also an extensive photo gallery featuring behind-the-scenes photos, production stills, different versions of the theatrical poster, and impressive work by photographer Peter Braatz who visited Lynch on the set. Finally, there's the theatrical trailer and several TV spots rounding out these terrific extras.The animated menu screens incorporate stylized renderings of shots from the film. Navigation is straightforward. There are several Easter Eggs to be discovered in the menu screens, leading to humorous, short interview excerpts. Unusual for a David Lynch film on DVD, both Region 1 and Region 2 versions do have Scene Selections menu screens and generous chapter stops.

Dan Hassler-Forest

Reviewed: August 26, 2002

Click here for IMDB info on Blue Velvet .

Click here to return to the front page.

© 2000-2006. A Remediated publication. All Rights Reserved. Site hosted by True