DVD Breakdown
Full reviews Capsule reviews Features Links About us
Gladiator (2001)

Ridley Scott
Russell Crowe, Joaquin Phoenix, Connie Nielsen, Oliver Reed, Djimon Hounsou, Richard Harris
Anamorphic widescreen
Dolby Digital 5.1
DTS
Trailer(s)
Featurette(s)
Documentary
Audio commentary
Deleted scenes
Concept art / storyboards
Multi-angle feature
Quote
Maximus Decimus Meridius: My name is Maximus Decimus Meridius, Commander of the Armies of the North, General of the Felix Legions, loyal servant to the true emperor, Marcus Aurelius. Father to a murdered son, husband to a murdered wife. And I will have my vengeance, in this life or the next.

Plot summary
A Roman general is betrayed, forced into slavery and becomes a legend in the gladiatorial arena.

Film review
This summer blockbuster from DreamWorks represented a return to form for a beloved movie genre that had been missing, presumed dead for decades: the historical epic. Having priced themselves out of existence in the early 1960s, most moviegoers of today will only have seen these cinematic juggernauts in faded pan & scan versions on Saturday afternoon TV. But now, thanks to CGI, the epic scale required to sell these movies has become more feasible, and without the religious trappings that make most of the older Roman epics heavy going, the genre seems to have come back into fashion, and it won't be long before we see more sword-and-sandals epics making their way onto the big screen.

Gladiator is a successful movie, and may be memorable for making a well-deserved star of Russell Crowe and bringing the Roman epic back to life, but it lacks greatness. In spite of some impressive CGI work that effectively recreates the size and grandeur of the Colosseum, the movie as a whole lacks the scale that made a classic like Spartacus and even a more recent adventure like Braveheart a monumental movie experience. It may have worked better had the story been given an extra half hour of screen time, as the proceedings feel somewhat rushed at 149 minutes. The screenplay also leaves little room for subtlety and gives the actors more than a few real clunkers of lines. Crowe and Phoenix still succeed against the odds in making the most of their parts, and Crowe just about ends up carrying the movie to its conclusion on little more than his personal charisma. He has an awesome on-screen presence and this movie at least gives him a stage big enough for his heroic persona.
Version control
Identical 2-disc versions are available for Region 1 and Region 2. Minor differences include the lack of chapter selection screen for the audio commentary track and the Chicken Run easter egg on the Region 2 release.

Picture and sound
The anamorphic widescreen image is framed at 2.35:1. The transfer is absolutely flawless, recreating the film's rich cinematography and showing a stunning amount of detail. Black levels are stable and deep, and the colors are rich and vibrant, with accurate fleshtones and remarkable rendering of the stylized segments.
The Dolby Digital 5.1 EX sound mix is very strong, with plenty of detail in the sound design and a deep and wide soundstage with excellent directional effects. The DTS EX 6.1 sound mix is even more impressive, with more detail in the higher frequencies and more overwhelming effects in the action sequences.

Added value
This extraordinarily rich and well-designed 2-disc special edition sets a new standard for DVD releases. Not only does it include a reference quality transfer of the film and both DD and DTS sound mixes, it comes with a great set of extra features that have been chosen and presented with great care, and that succeed in adding greatly to the film.

The first disc features an audio commentary track from director Ridley Scott together with cinematographer John Mathison and editor Pietro Scalia. Unsurprisingly, Scott is the main speaker of the three, while Scalia hardly seems to say anything at all. The director doesn't come across as a terribly sympathetic character in his commentaries: he sounds rather cold and distant, and gives a rather arrogant and defensive impression. It's still an informative commentary, even though Scott has a tendency to (over)state the obvious in his attempts to add insight to the storyline and character development.

Disc number 2 holds a plethora of extra features, all of which are worthwhile and well-presented. The Deleted Scenes section is presented like the deleted scenes on the Alien DVD, with a list of scenes that each have a preview still and a text description. All the scenes can be viewed with or without director's commentary. An item from this section that deserves special mention is called 'the treaseure chest'; it's a 7-minute montage of unused footage, edited together by Pietro Scalia and scored by Hans Zimmer. It includes shots that had to be cut to get an R-rating as they were perceived to be overly violent, and it also includes the alternate cut for the sequence in which Maximus' wife and child are killed. It's a real treat and one of the best items on the disc.
A 25-minute 'making-of' documentary is better than the standard promotional featurette, but fails to dig very deep beneath the film's glossy surface. It features behind-the-scenes footage, interviews with cast and crew, and the usual amount of brief clips from the film. The 50-minute documentary 'Gladiator Games' is much more interesting, providing some welcome historical background on the barbaric gladiator tradition in Rome. It incorporates some clips from the film to dramatically illustrate the history it refers to. Other features include a 20-minute section on Hans Zimmer's film score and 'My Gladiator Journal', a personal set diary from actor Spencer Treat Clark, who plays the young Lucius in the film.
Several galleries of storyboards, concept art and location photographs are carefully rendered, and are lots of fun to browse through. Don't miss the Easter Egg for the unused Rhino section that you'll find if you press the 'Up' button in the first frame of the Rhino storyboard. Rounding out this amazing disc is a selection of theatrical and TV trailers, with an Easter Egg on the Region 1 version containing a 'Gladiator Chicken Run' trailer.The animated menus open with a nicely processed montage of characters from the film that leads into the main menu screen featuring a desaturated view of Rome from atop the Colosseum. Brief transitional animations bring you to the other menu screens, all of which are beautifully designed in line with the look of the film. The 'Scene index' screen has animated previews of six scenes per screen and is easily navigated. The disc doesn't allow audio switching by using the 'Language' key on the remote, so to go from DD to DTS or to the audio commentary, you have to access the menu screens. This has the added drawback of having to start the movie over if you want to switch audio channels while watching.

Dan Hassler-Forest

Reviewed: 2001

Click here for IMDB info on Gladiator.

Click here to return to the front page.

© 2000-2006. A Remediated publication. All Rights Reserved. Site hosted by True