DVD Breakdown
Full reviews Capsule reviews Features Links About us
Platoon (1986)

Oliver Stone
Tom Berenger, Willem Dafoe, Charlie Sheen, Forest Whittaker, Francesco. Quinn, John C. McGinley, Richard Edson, Kevin Dillon, Reggie Johnson
Anamorphic widescreen
Dolby Digital 5.1
DTS
Trailer(s)
Featurette(s)
Documentary
Audio commentary
Deleted scenes
Concept art / storyboards
Multi-angle feature
Quote
Bunny: I told the padre the truth, man: I like it here. You get to do what you want. Nobody fucks with you. The only worry you got is dyin', and if that happens you won't know about it anyway. So what the fuck, man?

Plot summary
A visceral depiction of the Vietnam war as experienced by a platoon of infantry men.

Film review
Platoon provides a look of the Vietnam war from the point of view of the drafted men of the American army. Most of them came from the bottom of the social barrel and most of them hardly expected to survive. It makes for a sobering view as these soldiers don't really care about the enemy they're up against but instead are desperate to hold on to some semblance of humanity and trying to cope with the hardships of the jungle and the constant fear of dying. Some survive, some break down and others go insane. The story is based on Oliver Stone's own experiences as a soldier and his point of view in the movie is provided by Chris Taylor (Charlie Sheen), a naive young soldier who volunteered for the war. Stone builds up a great narrative as we view the war through the eyes of Chris, who quickly becomes numb to the horrors and dehumanizing combat. The action in the movie mirrors his accumulated experiences, starting with a relatively small ambush episode and ending with a horrifiying all-out assault by the Vietcong when an American base is overrun by suicide commandos.

Amidst all of this, Stone puts Chris between two opposing characters exemplifying the opposite extremes of America's involvement in Vietnam: the Christ-like, dope-smoking humane Elias (Willem Dafoe) and the devilish, utterly unsympathetic and kill-happy Barnes (Tom Berenger). Stone hammers the point home in the voice-over by Chris, pointing out "I think now, looking back, we did not fight the enemy, we fought ourselves. The enemy was in us." Platoon won an Oscar for best picture and it still holds up fifteen years later, with powerhouse performances from the three main leads and its overall impact luckily undiminshed by too many Tour Of Duty reruns.
Version control
There have been two earlier releases that have gone out of print, one of which features an audio commentary track from director Oliver Stone. Copies of this release are being sold for huge amounts on Ebay. MGM/UA first released a movie-only version, of which the Region 1 and Region 2 versions are identical [see separate review], and before long followed this up with a Special Edition release, also nearly identical for Region 1 and Region 2, and adding a documentary and two audio commentary tracks to the same transfer and audio mix. This review covers this Special Edition release.

Picture and sound
The picture is anamorphically enhanced and framed at 1.85:1. Colors are very good with plenty of detail. The picture quality is not consistent though, white specks and grain pop up from time to time. Overall I was very impressed with the picture though, having previously been exposed to the movie through very bad looking TV and video versions. It's great to finally see everything during the night-time jungle scenes.
The Dolby Digital 5.1 mix is a dissapointment: the rear channels are badly used (they sometimes drop out and then fade in again, very irritating) and the overall sound lacks definition with almost everything coming from the center channel (the dope smoking session to the tune of 'Tracks Of My Tears' is decidedly underwhelming on this soundtrack). Fortunately the dialogue doesn't suffer from all this, and my guess is that the original track just isn't very good: the movie was made for a low budget of $6 million, which may have something to do with it.

Added value
This welcome new Special Edition release of Oliver Stone's memorable Oscar-winner boasts quite a few tantalizing new extras, including an audio commentary track from the director himself. Stone is always interesting to listen to, as he has proved on several other DVD and Laserdisc releases, but on this track his mumbled comments often verge on the unintelligible, and is interspersed with long pauses and sections where he merely describes what is happening on-screen. Not so for the commentary track from military adviser Dale Dye, who also makes an appearance in the movie and who has performed in other movie roles since. He was responsible for drilling the young cast on location in the Phillipines, and proves to have played a very important part in the filmmaking process. His remarks are articulate, to-the-point and almost always scene-specific, making this by far the better of the two commentary tracks.
But even more engrossing is the 48-minute documentary that charts the fillm's entire production from inception to release, and includes plentiful behind-the-scenes footage and new interview footage of most principals of cast and crew. Making this movie was clearly no picnic, and an ordeal for the cast rivalled only by such legendary productions as The Abyss and Jaws. It makes for a most riveting documentary at least as entertaining as the movie itself.
Rounding out these impressive extras are the theatrical trailer and a selection of TV trailers.The menus are subtly animated without any sound.

Gerard Castelein and Dan Hassler-Forest

Reviewed: 2001

Click here for IMDB info on Platoon.

Click here to return to the front page.

© 2000-2006. A Remediated publication. All Rights Reserved. Site hosted by True