DVD Breakdown
Full reviews Capsule reviews Features Links About us
Se7en (1995)

David Fincher
Brad Pitt, Morgan Freeman, Gwyneth Paltrow and Kevin Spacey
Anamorphic widescreen
Dolby Digital 5.1
DTS
Trailer(s)
Featurette(s)
Documentary
Audio commentary
Deleted scenes
Concept art / storyboards
Multi-angle feature
Quote
Detective Somerset: "This isn't going to have a happy ending."

Plot summary
Two homicide detectives go on a desperate search for a serial killer who uses the seven deadly sins as his calling card.

Film review
The release and commercial success of Se7en was like a bomb going off under the conventional Hollywood thriller. With a screenplay specifically designed, Tyler Durden-like, to upset audience expectations and an overpowering visual style that brings the viewer as close to a sensation of Hell as one would like to get, its schoolboy-style pranksterism is offset by its sombre and disturbing outlook on society. But though its visual style has redefined its genre's aesthetics, all subsequent imitations (and there have been quite a few so far) have fallen back on more audience-friendly narrative thriller conventions. Darker and much more disturbing than the previous 'definitive' serial killer movie The Silence of the Lambs, Fincher's breakthrough piece strips the killer mythos of all its gothic trappings and reduces its heroes to ineffectual detectives following and documenting the trail the killer lays out for them. The killer is the only character in the film with any influence over the development of the film's narrative, while Brad Pitt's character is the embodiment of audience expectations for traditional police thrillers. And as the narrative sets him up for the ultimate fall, so does it set up the audience.

The movie has been criticized for drenching the viewer in ugliness, and I certainly wouldn't recommend it to those with a strong belief in the fundamental goodness of humanity. It's a movie that offers a diagnosis, not a cure, as neither detective is able to counter any of John Doe's arguments for doing what he did. As played by Kevin Spacey, John Doe is a controlled, intelligent force of evil that only Somerset understands you can't argue with. His character provides the movie with its soul: the challenging thought that evil cannot be vanquished but one must nevertheless keep fighting may prove too gloomy for many a viewer, but still sets this contemporary classic leagues apart from would-be imitations like The Bone Collector and Copycat. Se7en sees the good guys go down without even a fighting chance, and though it's a rough ride, it's one you really should take.
Version control
Previously released as a flipper disc in Region 1 and a mediocre Dolby Surround presentation in Region 2, the R1 New Line Platinum Series 2-disc set is now the only DVD version of this film worth your while. It has been released in Region 2 in two slightly different versions, one for the UK and one for the Netherlands and Belgium [see separate R2 review]. This review deals only with the R1 version.

Picture and sound
The anamorphic widescreen image is framed at 2.35:1. This is an incredible presentation, struck from the original negative under David Fincher's personal supervision. The movie has never looked like this before, not in theaters and not on the laserdisc. Detail in every shot is clear and overwhelming, as are the colours (all newly color-corrected). The only flaws I detected are some shimmering edges in indoor scenes and light moire patterns on the outsides of buildings, but it's never distracting.

The audio mix has had a complete working over, with a near field mix used to fully immerse the viewer. It's been specifically mixed for DVD, and both the Dolby Digital EX 5.1 mix and the DTS ES 6.1 mix are terrific. I found the DTS to be slightly boomy at times but it does provide a wider soundstage than the DD track. Dialogue in the opening scenes is a bit harder to follow due to the very present rain sounds in the audio mix but that's the only time it's a bit too much. The chase scene and the opening title sequence with the Nine Inch Nails track are great pieces to check your settings.

Added value
New Line has provided four audio commentary tracks on the first disc with each commentary dealing with a specific element of the movie:
  • "The Stars" is a commentary from director David Fincher with actors Brad Pitt and Morgan Freeman. Fincher and Pitt are recorded together and there's a relaxed atmosphere as the two remember their experiences during the production and talking about their thoughts on getting the movie out as Fincher and Pitt wanted (check for the "the people who made this movie should be killed" remark). Freeman analyzes his performance and how he works with different directors.
  • "The Story" is the most informative and has author and film critic Richard Dyer, Screenwriter Andrew Kevin Walker, editor Richard Francis-Bruce, president of production at New Line Michael De Luca and David Fincher, all recorded separately. Dyer is the track's host and he focuses on the story structure, images and subject matter. Walker provides details about the inspirations and thoughts about the subject matter, as does Fincher.
  • "The Picture" is a commentary from Richard Dyer, David Fincher, editor Richard Francis-Bruce, cinematographer Darius Khondji and production designer Arthur Max. As expected, this is the most technical of the commentaries but still interesting and makes you appreciate the enormous amount of detail in the movie.
  • "The Sound" has comments by Richard Dyer, David Fincher, composer Howard Shore and sound designer Ren Klyce (who adds the most interesting remarks). When the commentary is silent, the isolated score in Dolby Digital 5.1 is playing. And as Fincher says 'there's sound everywhere' so this is obviously an important and interesting aspect of the overall picture and one you don't hear described in detail that often.

The second disc has great extras but the most satisfying aspect of it all is that everything on this disc is presented in anamorphic quality, which greatly adds to the quality of the overall package. Another great thing is the presentation of most of the extras in pieces ranging from 5 to 15 minutes, with subtly underscored music and commentary on top. It all adds up to a relaxed viewing of all these extras and it's the first time with a special edition DVD of this scale that I managed to take it all in in a single viewing.
There's a great presentation on how this DVD was optimized for the home theater with commentaries from the people involved in aspects of audio mastering, video mastering, color correction and the Telecine gallery (where the viewer can experience the differences between the original release and the new release in three scenes with the audio and angle buttons allowing the viewer to go back and forth). The same method is used for the opening title sequence exploration, with different commentaries, angles and audio options (Dolby Digital EX, DTS ES, Stereo Surround Sound or 24bit/96k stereo). The deleted scenes section contains extensions of existing scenes with the exception of a different opening sequence. These scenes can be viewed with an optional commentary by director David Fincher. Also included here is an animated storyboard sequence for an original opening with a train scene. The alternate ending is not that different from the one we all know, but is great with the optional commentary from director David Fincher, as is an animated set of storyboards for an ending that was not filmed. Very impressive are the photo gallery of production designs presented in video with music and commentary and John Doe's snapshots of Victor's decomposition and crime scene photos used in the film, all with commentary. The creation of John Doe's notebooks is covered in a special featurette with commentary from the people involved. Also a theatrical trailer, the orginal electronic press kit (a featurette for the movie) and some great DVD-ROM material. Right from the bat you know this is going to be an awesome DVD in every aspect: all the menus are done in sync with the look and design of the movie, with easy navigation to all the different screens. The ambient sounds are everywhere as are the John Doe character's notebook layouts.

Dan Hassler-Forest & Gerard Castelein

Reviewed: 2001

Click here for IMDB info on Se7en.

Click here to return to the front page.

© 2000-2006. A Remediated publication. All Rights Reserved. Site hosted by True