Full reviews Capsule reviews Features Links About us
May 5, 2008
 
   
I'm Not There
Taxi Driver: SE
Labyrinth: SE
Close Encounters of the Third Kind: Ann. Edition
300: Special Edition
The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford
The Shield: Season 5
I Am Legend
Seinfeld: Season 9
Vacancy
The Shield: Season 4
Talk to the Hand
51 Birch Street
Jailhouse Rock
This is Elvis
The Bad Sleep Well
Boudu Saved from Drowning
Ugetsu
Le Samouraï
Burden of Dreams
F for Fake
The River
Thieves' Highway
Night and the City
Kagemusha
 
DVD Top 10: 2007
DVD Top 10: 2006
DVD Top 10: 2004
DVD Top 10: 2003
DVD Top 10: 2002
DVD Top 10: 2001
DVD Essentials
François Truffaut
David Lynch
Oliver Stone
Stanley Kubrick
Clint Eastwood
 

I'm Not There

Given the recent spate of popular biopics on iconic popular musicians like Ray Charles and Johnny Cash, the appearance of a feature film documenting the most mercurial, brilliant and influential musician of the twentieth century is hardly surprising. The good news is that the project appeared not in the reductionist form of these recent successes (the conventions and clichés of which were recently mocked in the hilarious Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story). Instead, the iconoclastic writer-director Toddy Haynes decided to create a film that is actually about the basic impossibility of grasping the core of such a celebrity.

Illustrating Dylan's fundamental unknowability, Haynes famously cast six different actors to play various manifestations of just a few of the many Dylan myths and images, ranging from a black boy (embodying the singer's own fictionalization of a mythic past) to the stunning Cate Blanchett (as the skeletal 'Dylan-gone-electric' teetering on the edge of a complete breakdown). Using both original Dylan music and inspired new performances of tracks both iconic and obscure, Haynes has managed to create a form that pays tribute to the musician while investigating our culture's tendency to mythologize and pin down human figures who are overwhelmed by their own celebrity. The only caveat may be that the film has a tendency to depend on an above-average familiarity with the singer's biography, making large parts of the film all but incomprehensible to those with only a passing interest in His Royal Bobness.

• full review •

The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford
There is probably no film genre that has been deconstructed, revised and revisited more often in American history than that of the Western. The way it has always straddled that central American paradox of mythologizing bandits and outlaws while reaffirming law and order makes it especially potent in times of national identity crisis: the recent high-profile appearances of the genre (There Will Be Blood, No Country for Old Men, 3:10 to Yuma) are similar in more ways than one to the revisionist Westerns that emerged post-Vietnam in the 1970s, such as Little Big Man and Buffalo Bill and the Indians, or Sitting Bull's History Lesson). Fitting in seamlessly with the aforementioned recent Westerns, The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford functions as a fractured mirror that reflects our contemporary concerns, ranging from the ways in which the popular media frame and distort both contemporary and historical events to the eerie feeling that our heroes are little more than psychopaths glorified by those who seek to emulate their image more than their actions.
Australian director Andrew Dominik brings a leisurely, lyrical sense to his adaptation of Ron Hansen's novel, stunningly visualizing the past in long widescreen takes of desolate landscapes and broken-down homes, but never surrendering to the temptation of again glorifying that which the film seeks to criticize. Brad Pitt is exceptioinally good here as the edgy, morose Jesse James, but among the astonishing cast, Casey Affleck is the true stand-out, delivering a performance that is truly uncanny in its nervous fawning and rudderless yearning for recognition.
The DVD, packaged in a handsomely designed but easily damaged faux-wood container, features a strikingly flawless transfer and terrifically immersive 5.1 audio, but no extras of any kind.

© 2000-2007. A Laputa publication . All Rights Reserved. Site hosted by True
This site really does look better on a Macintosh computer.