DVD Breakdown
Full reviews Capsule reviews Features Links About us
Diary of a Country Priest [Journal d'un Curé de Campagne] (1951)

Robert Bresson
Claude Laydu, Léon Arvel, Antoine Balpêtré, Jean Danet, Jeanne Etiévant
Anamorphic widescreen
Dolby Digital 5.1
DTS
Trailer(s)
Featurette(s)
Documentary
Audio commentary
Deleted scenes
Concept art / storyboards
Multi-angle feature
Quote
Curé d'Ambricourt (Claude Laydu): Our hidden sins poison the air that others breathe.

Plot summary
A young sick priest arrives in his first parish, a village in the North of France, but is ostracized by the community.

Film review
I well remember the first time I saw Robert Bresson's highly acclaimed cinematic masterpiece. I was in my second year of film school, and classes on Friday mornings were always followed by screenings of classic films in one of the biggest on-screen auditoriums. On this particular Friday, I had excitedly invited a friend of mine along to the screening, as the film on the schedule was Buster Keaton's The General, and we were both in the mood for some high-spirited physical comedy after a long week of studying postmodern film theory. Bus as was often the case, there had been a change in the schedule, and the film that was screened on that Friday turned out to be something close to the antithesis of that masterpiece of silent comedy.

About half the students in the auditorium stood up and walked out as soon as the announcement was made, but since Diary of a Country Pries was also a milestone in cinema history that we hadn't yet seen, we decided to remain seated and give it a shot. What followed were two of the longest hours of my life, as the slow suffering of the poor young priest unspooled at a snail's pace before our eyes. Given our state of mind, the tragic narrative failed to make much of an impact on us, nor did the celebrated cinematography (projected from a blurry VHS tape via a video beamer) strike us as particularly memorable. Suggestions like 'Go to a doctor already' and 'Move to another village' came to mind throughout, and were even uttered on occasion as the film dragged on. But doggedly (if misguidedly) determined to sit the film out, we were two of the few viewers who stayed until the end, and had a good laugh afterwards, confidently labeling this film the epitome of overrated, pretentious cinéma du boring.

Revisiting the film for the first time since that memorable afternoon more than a decade ago, the experience is of course completely the opposite. Not so much a matter as being old enough to appreciate it as it is of approaching the film in the appropriate state of mind and the right viewing circumstances, Diary of a Country Priest is an almost unbearably pure, uncluttered vision of hope clashing with existential despair. The impeccably framed, gorgeously shot film has a hypnotic pull over the viewer as it follows its protagonist's doomed attempts to reach out to his unhospitable parishioners. A film both unique and highly influential, it's a picture that can hardly be recommended highly enough (although I would caution those intending to watch in an overly jocular mood).
Version control
Available only as a Region 1 release from the Criterion Collection.

Picture and sound
The fullscreen image is framed at its original aspect ratio of approx. 1.33:1. The print has clearly suffered over the years, as can be seen throughout in the vertical lines that appear along the sides of the frame, as well as from occasional scratches that show up incidentally. But the image is very sharp, with excellent, consistent grayscale and contrast, allowing the cinematography to shine more clearly than it ever did on videocassette.
The original mono sound mix is presented in Dolby Digital 1.0, and is rather low on fidelity but certainly up to the task of presenting this deceptively simple soundtrack.

Added value
The only major extra on this long-awaited Bressonian masterpiece is an audio commentary track by film historian Peter Cowie, and for once, a Criterion commentary is something of a mixed bag. Cowie spends much of his time discussing differences between the film and the novel it was based on, which can be illuminating but often digresses into the recounting of interminable episodes from the book. Cowie also has an annoying tendency to draw upon his own experiences with vicars, making him sound not only dull but also unbearably pompous. He's an experienced speaker and well versed in Bressonian lore, so the track is hardly a waste of time. But it doesn't quite live up to the high standards we've come to expect from the Criterion Collection's scholarly commentary tracks. The theatrical trailer is also on-board, and a rather obtuse essay, reprinted from an issue of Film Comment, is to be found in the booklet.Ethereal animated menu screens live up to the high standards usually upheld by Criterion DVD releases.

Dan Hassler-Forest

Reviewed: May 3, 2003

Click here for IMDB info on Diary of a Country Priest.

Click here to return to the front page.

© 2000-2006. A Remediated publication. All Rights Reserved. Site hosted by True