DVD Breakdown
Full reviews Capsule reviews Features Links About us
Eraserhead (1978)

David Lynch
Jack Nance, Charlotte Stewart, Allen Joseph, Jeanne Bates
Anamorphic widescreen
Dolby Digital 5.1
DTS
Trailer(s)
Featurette(s)
Documentary
Audio commentary
Deleted scenes
Concept art / storyboards
Multi-angle feature
Quote
Mr. X (Allen Joseph): Well Henry, what do you know?
Henry Spencer (Jack Nance): Oh, I don't know much of anything.

Plot summary
A dream of dark and troubling things.

Film review
In an industry that thrives on the continuous regestation of its own imagery, few things are as rare as a successful director who is at the same time an artist with a vision that is fully an uncompromisingly his own. David Lynch is such a director: a filmmaker whose every work transports you into a fully realized world that may be strange, scary, wistful, funny or deeply unsettling, but that's unlike anything you've experienced before. Completely ignoring every possible rule of classical narrative filmmaking even in his most generally accessible (and commercially successful) films, Lynch instead tends to follow a dream logic. But unlike most experimental directors who attempt similar work, Lynch's vision is so specific, his worlds so convincing and his ideas so captivating that he only very rarely loses his stranglehold on the viewer. His unique combination of nerve-jangling creepiness and down-home sense of humor plays a key part in this.

Of course, there are still many who wouldn't touch a David Lynch film with a ten-foot pole. And indeed, most of his films not only require the viewer to let go of any preconceived notions of what film is, and be taken along on an experiential ride that can be difficult to watch at times. For non-fans, Eraserhead has all the reasons for staying away from this particular director: it's a nearly plotless nightmare in which a bizarre-looking nobody in an unspecified but vastly detailed industrial city environment must somehow deal with the clearly non-human baby that he is said to have fathered. Meanwhile, he is terrorized by various sorts of gruesome and grotesque visions, finally culminating in an experience that explains the title. It's the midnigh movie par excellence, and is recommended only for those with a strong stomach, a brave sense of humor and a passion for true cinema. But for those who can handle the fact that Eraserhead is a filmic nightmare that's creepy, funny and unlike anything you've ever seen, it's a brilliantly visualized comedy of terrors that continues to defy its age and still stands among its unique director's finest work.
Version control
A pan-and-scan fullscreen DVD is available for Region 2 in the UK and for Region 4, without any extras. David Lynch owns the American domestic distribution rights to the film himself, and has released the definitive DVD edition of Eraserhead himself, available only through his store at DavidLynch.com. This Region 1 version served as the basis for this review.

Picture and sound
The anamorphic widescreen image is framed at an aspect ratio of approx. 1.85:1. Lynch himself put his debut feature through a painstaking six-month restoration process during which each individual frame was cleaned up and fully restored to mirror the filmmaker's intentions. The result is nothing short of breathtaking, especially to viewers used to seeing the film in battered 16mm prints or washed-out VHS tapes drawn from a poor master. Detail is abundant and precise throughout, bringing into view for the first time on home video the incredible level of detail that went into every element of the production design, and the masterful organic quality of the disconcertingly gorgeous cinematography.
The soundtrack has also been fully restored in order to minimize any flaws resulting from the technical process. The booklet lists the soundtrack format as PCM uncompressed stereo, but the track on the disc is actually a Dolby Digital 2.0 mix (most likely a last-minute change due to lack of disc space). It's still a hugely impressive audio presentation that decodes very well using a ProLogic receiver. Bass is much stronger than is usually the case with 2.0 audio mixes, and although surround effects are naturally absent, the highly detailed front soundstage is still highly immersive.

Added value
David Lynch has reputation as a difficult, 'weird' director who refuses to discuss his work on-camera and makes all sorts of outlandish demands (like the absence of chapter stops on DVDs of his films) from his distributors. His feeling that films should not be explained but experienced by each viewer from his or her own perspective has led to a general reluctance on the director's part to participate in any but the technical aspects of DVD productions of his films so far.

For the DVD of Eraserhead, however, Lynch has created a 90-minute documentary - fittingly called 'Stories' - in which he covers every conceivable aspect of the film's background and production. The documentary consists of little else besides Lynch talking, while his memories are illustrated by stills and some rare on-set footage shot during production, but it's amazingly engrossing from start to finish. Lynch is an outstanding storyteller with an unpretentious, folksy attitude and a real gift for recounting his memories of this extraordinary film project. He speaks generously and graciously about his collaborators on the film, and at one point even calls his key assistant Catherine Coulson (well-known among Twin Peaks fans for her role as the Log Lady) on the speaker phone. (His impromptu yelling out of questions hilariously brings to mind his own small role as deaf FBI Chief Gordon Cole in the same series.) The documentary's form may be unusual, but it's a highly appropriate and definitive supplement that makes any other extras pretty much irrelevant. (Deleted footage from the film is discussed within it, but has unfortunately all been lost.) The incredible trailer is also included, in anamorphic widescreen.The menu screens, animated and designed in the style of Lynch's website, start off with a simple calibration test to make sure the viewer's monitor isn't set too brightly. Animation options are overlaid on a short scene that was cut from the final film playing in the background, accompanied by industrial ambient sound. It takes a little while for navigation options to appear, but its presentation is simple, elegant and uncluttered. As with most David Lynch films on DVD, there are no chapter stops in the film.

Dan Hassler-Forest

Reviewed: April 29, 2003

Click here for IMDB info on Eraserhead.

Click here to return to the front page.

© 2000-2006. A Remediated publication. All Rights Reserved. Site hosted by True