DVD Breakdown
Full reviews Capsule reviews Features Links About us
The Horse's Mouth (1958)

Ronald Neame
Alec Guinness, Kay Walsh, Renee Houston, Mike Morgan, Ernest Thesiger
Anamorphic widescreen
Dolby Digital 5.1
DTS
Trailer(s)
Featurette(s)
Documentary
Audio commentary
Deleted scenes
Concept art / storyboards
Multi-angle feature
Quote
Nosey (Mike Morgan): The world needs artists!
Gulley Jimson (Alec Guinness): Lunatics, too.  But don’t go putting yourself into an asylum any sooner than you have to!

Plot summary
Artist Gulley Jimson strives for nothing but perfection of his vision, mostly unsuccessfully and with complete disregard for the lives of others.

Film review
His face is permanently engraved on the world's collective memory as the aging Obi-Wan Kenobi in the original Star Wars trilogy. But given a choice, I feel certain that Alec Guinness would have preferred to be remembered for his portrayal of Gulley Jimson, the down-and-out painter so obsessive about his work that he never could get an even break. But then again, it does seem fitting that Guinness's most personal work should ultimately survive as a small, unknown gem, to be discovered by new audiences eager to see more of Guinness's 'early' work.

The film's relative obscurity is somehow well-suited to the film's theme of an artist's obsessive vision and its dry, elegiac tone. Guinness's droll screenplay adapts Joyce Carey's novel as a series of occurrences rather than a plot-driven narrative. The film's momentum relies solely on Guinness's performance as the gravel-voiced Jimson, whose gruff manner and lack of manners conceal a brilliant artist struggling to bring his vision to life. Director Ronald Neame does little more than keep things together, only barely steering clear of occasional descents into broad farce. And though it may lack the tight narrative structure of the Ealing comedies that made Guinness a well-known actor, the glimpses of vulnerability under Jimson's hard shell give The Horse's Mouth an undercurrent of pathos that can be truly moving.
Version control
Only available on DVD from the Criterion Collection as a Region 1 release.

Picture and sound
The anamorphic widescreen image is framed at an aspect ratio of approx. 1.66:1. The image presented here looks as bright and colorful as it ever will, having undergone some solid restoration efforts that have successfully freed it of scratches, dirt and various other debris. The early Technicolor cinematography looks a little pale, but that is typical of the process used at this time in the 1950s, and the transfer on this DVD manages to impress throughout.
The monaural sound mix is also more than satisfactory, anchored in the center Dolby Digital channel. The limited dynamics are most evident in the musical score, which sounds tinny and sometimes muffled, but dialogues come across sounding natural and very clear, as do most sound effects.

Added value
This director-approved DVD release is graced by a nicely edited 19-minute interview with director Ronald Neame, who talks at length about how the project was started, and what the nature of his involvement was, as well as that of actor/screenwriter Alec Guinness. Generously illustrated with film clips, stills and other images, this interview covers all the bases on this film's production history. The theatrical trailer (which doesn't give a very reliable impression at all of the film) is really the only other film-related extra on the disc. But three excellent essays on various aspects of the film are collected in the beautifully designed booklet that accompanies it. Criterion Collection releases have of late been structurally enhanced more frequently with great information in nicely designed booklets that manage to demonstrate yet again how much easier it is to read long text from the page than it would have been from the screen.

Separate mention must go to the inclusion of D.A. Pennebaker's first commercially released short film 'Daybreak Express', a gorgeously impressionist collage of images picturing New York City and its subway trains at daybreak. This 6-minute film opened the bill when The Horse's Mouth first played in New York, so it's provided here for completion's sake more than anything else. Showing how they always manage to go the extra yard when it comes to DVD extras, the DVD producers even taped a 2.5-minute interview with Pennebaker in which he talks about how his first film sale came about. All of this of course doesn't really have very much to do with the main feature on the disc, but it's a great inclusion that illustrates the quality of work unique to the Criterion Collection. The drawing used as art for the poster forms the background image for the static main menu screen, which is accompanied by the main Prokofiev theme from the film. Navigation throughout is as carefully and pleasantly designed as one has come to expect from Criterion Collection releases.

Dan Hassler-Forest

Reviewed: July 1, 2002

Click here for IMDB info on The Horse's Mouth.

Click here to return to the front page.

© 2000-2006. A Remediated publication. All Rights Reserved. Site hosted by True